I played abbasid since launch
it was fun at the start with lower elo until u meet your match and the civs bonus decide if u win or lose
turned out later they are the worst civ now in the ladder with 42% winrate for +1500 elo
https://aoe4world.com/stats/civilizations?rating=>1500
one huge disadventage with abbasid is that when u age up you dont get your bonus while all other civs do
instead u have to waste another min and bunch of resources to get your bonus
My suggestion is:
abbasid age up in one min instead of 2 (to keep up with other civs age time)
abbasid get the first bonus of their wing for free upon age up
change camel rider dmg from (9+18) to (18 + 9) to make it useful vs other units
lower camel archers cost
everyone is tired of same old meta (mongol / rus / french) deminating the leaderboard
i hope my feedback will be take to consideration
otherwise this game remain rus and mong simulator