Yea no one likes things to be removed so i feel ya.
Other options would be removing Plate Barding Armor or Husbandry, those would make things a lot worse and ruin the civ.
Also there is a simple and bland route to just remove 20% hp buff and give Franks free Bloodlines… but thats kinda boring fix.
You say they already spam castles and then say Blast Furnace is the only thing going for them, those 2 are not related. Also castle discount could be made by split - Castle age -20% and Imperial age -30% discount.
No it is just weird for franks. Franks are “the” paladin civ. And you want to remove one of the important upgrades, making frank paladins worse than teutons, lith, persians, spanish…
It just doesn’t makes sense.
Also the other changes you propose are weird and you didn’t brought up any explanation why you want these weird changes. I don’t get what you want to achieve with these changes.
Now gonna ask you what kind of games are you playing lol
I’m vocal about nerfing Franks but you suggest ridiculous and arbitrary ways to do it, remove castle discount? Franks already lack bracer. Farm Upgrades? this one dates from AOK, Buffing Foragers? That bonus was nerfed and you want it reverted or even better wtf? Reverting Chivalry and Bearded Axe? LMAO Chivalry is nothing but a broken tech which effect has to go lol.
Am I even saying removing forager bonus??
No, keep the eco advantages but nerf the stupid Imperial Age UT, change the effect (Fallen Knights return 33% of the gold, nerfs them by a lot in TGs but at the same time helps them in 1v1 when the gold starts to run out). Also if you want, the cavalry HP bonus applies in the castle age (Franks will still keep the eco advanatges in feudal, but they won’t have supremacy at scout rushing anymore, and they will have to use such eco advantages to reach castle age sooner as their scouts will fall hard in late feudal).
This would be totally OP on TGs actually.
IMO the best approach is indeed to adjust their eco bonusses - I personally would remove the forager bonus to make it free for other civs and in the exchange give a minimal buff to their lategame cav like cav having 25 % HP in imp. Maybe this could also instead be an adjustment to chivalry - instead of making stables faster Chivalry could give extra HP to their cav.
And TGs: They need an overhaul in general. It isn’t franks or britons fault that there is this stale knight/arche rmeta.
24G per fallen Knight, not even close to what was going to be the Burgundian bonus (50% gold back, and that was a civ bonus so in castle age it started), you need to lose like 3 paladins to get the price of 1 back, also btw in team games there’s trade anyway.
As for 1v1 it will be in Imperial Age anyway, where Franks have poor military units when gold is out. Also, still respects the Chivalry theme of French cavalry if you want to know.
Your wording was like you though i suggested buffing foragers speed back to 25% while not removing free farm upgrades. Maybe i misunderstood.
I do like the Fallen Knight UT, but it should be 20% maybe max 25% not 33%. But as a pure one-dimensional Paladin civ, 1 of the 3 non cav bonuses needs to go. The main Paladin civ having so many non cav bonuses is wierd…
Is it even reasonable to keep a so one-dimensional civ in current well established TG meta - Archers + Paladins in almost every game. To change the TG meta seems a lot harder to do than make one-dimensional civs a bit more flexible but weaker on their main aspect.
Like Briton archers and Frank Paladins.
Well you have to look at the Franks tech tree, outside of paladins, their other military options are very limited, the Infantry is ok but other civs have better barrack units and infantry UUs, their archery range is really poor, siege not spectacular, etc.
Yes i agree with you. That was actually the premise of my topic. How to bring down Frank Paladin spam to level of other top tier pocket civs, so we wont have a clear dominating Paladin civ.
Doing that while compensating them somewhere else to not make them garbage in 1v1. In TG you just spam Paladins as Frank. Nerfing Knight-line spam to match the rest top pocket civs would cripple them in 1v1 as at the moment knight-line spam is their only viable option in 1v1
Spamming knight-line is not nearly as effective in 1v1 as it is in TG.
I totally agree with the Blast Furnace thing, though it won’t work, most people are single dimensional in their approach to the game, they wont accept this change, think that Franks are a Knight civ, which is pretty much dumb-down to this whole strategy game, but okay.
That’s kind of just a worse thing then Szlachta Privileges. It’s Imp instead of Castle, has a weaker effect, and only applies if the knight dies first. People are typically encouraged to try and keep their units alive, so it seems kind of pointless as a whole. I agree current Chivalry needs a nerf though.