Sorry to tell you that. But you are the one who goes
And somehow argue that certain stuff that was abslutely real in medieval history shouldn’t “fit” in the game because of that.
Why doesn’t “fit” something real from the medieval ages not in a medieval game? Because of a modern categoric of tribal names? That isn’t even applied in general?
Ofc Crusader States fit in a medieval empire rts game like AOE2.
Do I argue to add it rn? No.
And seemingly a lot of people think it fits. And I would argue that the real discussion is actually more about do we really want to add it before we run out of good representantive civs, everybody likes. (Cause many will see Crusader States as antagonistic civs)
But there are various other empires we would “dissallow” arbitrarily just because we can’t find a single tribal culture as representative. Including stuff like the HRE. And that shows how absurd it is to try apply modern categorics like these to a medieval game. And especially not selectively.
If a something was real at that time there should be a way to implement it. And I am against using modern categorics to dissallow stuff selectively. There might be other reasons why we maybe don’t want to have certain stuff ofc.
I think the best approach for a Holy Roman Empire-themed DLC would be to rename the “Teutons” to the “Teutonic Order,” add Crusader units via the editor, launch a Northern Crusades campaign, and introduce two new factions—the Holy Roman Empire and the Hanseatic League—along with their respective campaigns.
Next, plan a DLC themed around mercenaries and knights, introducing Venice and Switzerland, while also adding the Battle of Genoa in Italy.
I think naming civs after tribal names is actually what is potentially problematic.
Nationalists and Racists will come to our Community and funnily with this kind of naming we unfortunately give them an opportunity to spread their twisted narratives. It would be way harder for them to hide their true intentions if we had empire names instead.
They are so iconic they should really be trainable by someone.
I like the idea of a UU that can switch weapons, but not for free. Like you can switch them from Sword to Halberd but you need to pay 5-10 Gold. They would have like 3-4 different weapons available that all do different bonus damage. Halberd (bonus vs. Cavalry), Pike (1.8 range like Phalangite), Zweihänder (AoE damage), Arquebus (ranged attack) and drums (Aura that increases nearby movement and attack speed).
Some modes would be locked behind a UT (like Arquebus) and this UT would also enable a button that allows you to switch between modes. That button would be in the same place in the UI as the UT after you research it.
I don’t like the idea of crusaders civs… but I would like templars as a regional unit for western civs as a representation of the holy orders in the region
In the English version of the game at least, all civilization names are a single-word only. Besides, it’d narrow the civ’s scope too much – even if we want to split other civilizations out of the Teutons, it isn’t good to restrict their identity solely to the holy order. I’d like to keep Teutons as a civilization that covers both the Order and central&eastern Germans.
That’s neither a people grup nor a state, just an alliance of North German and Baltic cities.
Whether we are talking about Balts, Low Germans, High Germans, or Alemanni—at this point, I see no need for further discussion. It seems to me that the Byzantines, too, have evolved from a specific political entity into a naturally developed ethnocultural category. I simply don’t get it: people want a civilization to embody characteristics spanning multiple eras, yet they refuse to accept a narrower scope or a blend of elements that covers too wide a timespan; they even treat clearly defined, explicit symbols as taboo. Come on—the game’s original developers conceived East Asian architecture based on Chinatown fast-food joints and believed that half of 20th-century America was plagued by famine; I fail to see the point of this kind of debate. If we were to discuss creating entirely new architectural sets based on the regimes of these peoples across different eras—much like in the game *Rise of Nations*—another group would inevitably raise equally trivial objections. If that’s the sort of discussion we’re looking at, we really shouldn’t waste everyone’s time.
The Hanseatic League could actually find representation through the Saxon civ had it covered high medieval continental Saxons instead of only the Anglo-Saxons they seem to cover now The very narrow scope of the Viking Sagas DLC also robbed us of the high medieval Danish kingdom and the Kalmar Union of Queen Margaret.
I think this is primarily because Northern Europe during the Christian era lacked truly distinctive characteristics—even in terms of architecture. Given that the game prioritizes campaign gameplay, this lack of distinctiveness was almost inevitable; consequently, the issue could simply be resolved by swapping architectural sets. As for unique units? With limited unit slots, it is difficult to accommodate two units that differ vastly in style or era simultaneously. This creates a need for more granular differentiation to introduce additional units—unless, of course, there is enough pressure to prompt the developers to create a dedicated editor for custom content, or if the solution relies on graphical mods (which is the approach taken by the Italian Wars mod created by our Chinese community).
I’ve never really seen anyone ask Chinese players what they think of the unit designs in dlc Three Kingdoms—aside from the battles, that is. And speaking of unit designs… oh, the Zhuge Nu—the eternal Zhuge Nu—as if the Chinese have been fighting with repeating crossbows for 5,000 years.