Like obviously this is an extreme example, I doubt they’ll ever release a faction without a TC, but can you explain why, instead of simply stating it to be some kind of self-evidence fact?
Like the problem here seems to be that “asymmetry” means different things to different posters. What you consider “semi-asymmetric”, others already consider “too” asymmetric. No? Because we all have (valid) differences of opinion for what counts as familiar.
Finally, someone with some common sense on this forum! I agree that everything is different, but come on, the game is still pretty clear! Learn how to click on units and actually read… It took months for people to understand that Ballista Elephants were weak against Light Cavalry and Crossbows. Fun fact? It was literally written under the unit’s name when you clicked on it: heavy unit / siege. And honestly, it’s pretty obvious visually too!
If you don’t want to bother learning a game, just play some custom games and matches against the AI. Even Valorant is unbearable when you first start playing, because you have no idea what’s hitting you with all those agents… It’s perfectly normal to have to learn a game in order to survive in multiplayer! That’s how it works in every game!
Instead, just thank the developers for this amazing, highly original work that’s just as visually satisfying as it is fun to play!
That being said, you can absolutely help with balancing by intelligently pointing out the actual issues: 12 Mounted Pistoleers in the Castle Age being able to destroy a palisade in 2 seconds and sit under a TC for 5 minutes, for example; Elite catrans slaughtering a massive Genoese army (+ a Spearman frontline) in 5 seconds, even though they are theoretically supposed to counter them. The Viking booming is downright disgusting when you consider that the Forum produces slightly less than 150 food per minute. And so on…
There’s going to be a lot of balancing work to do, and after that, everything will go back to normal… just like after every DLC…
You made a very good point. The Genoese Crossbowmen are by far the weakest unit in the game. Regular Crossbowmen are much more useful and effective. Genoese Crossbowmen deal bonus damage against infantry, not heavy units. That’s why it’s perfectly understandable that they struggle against Cataphracts. What’s even stranger is that their attack speed is over 3 seconds, which makes absolutely no sense. Honestly, I feel sorry for Genoese Crossbowmen.
oups , i m french and lazy, I was meaing catrans, not acatacphracts!!! but chat gpt don’t know the scotts XD! And spear plus genois win against cataphract if you pay an equal ressources army
But the geois are basiclally handcannoers with up to 6.5 range! they are good but need some news way of use, compare to crossbow
Clever people figured it out way too early.Your learning curve is very slow i guess.Im talking about depth in game,soul of the game.When you look at the unit you need to tell what it is good for.
Yeah I konw, you prefer barking on something than most of the comunoty want: new civs. That’s literally the stuff wich give money to the devs. So, it’s the only things that keep the game alive. No more dlc/civs no more aoe4in 2 or 3 years, the game just shut down. Oh! In fact that would be no more dlc is killing the game!!!
What kills the game is the shift in priorities from providing a service to making money. We are seeing the consequences of this right now. For days, we’ve been dealing with ridiculous problems and imbalances while trying to play the game.
I agree, balancing is needed. But infortunetlly, the majority of player wants original new civs, not variants. But original ones is costing a shitty amount of money… really it s horrible just for the voice lines!!! So, even if it’s durty, I guess that it’s the same as the “bug” on torguts for GH, 1 year ago. One entiere month for fixing it??? Nah, they need to do it for getting money back. And the worst part? I 'm not even sure the game is making so much profits…
I’m not liking it eather than you… but if it’s the only way to get the game alive? Not like aoe3! People really need to be more pragmatic on how the wolrd is running: money… You can’t have a game alive without “buggued” DLC for the time to get back the hudge invest
Instead of three Chinese civilizations or three French civilizations, I would have preferred to see one French, one Chinese, one Spanish, and one Timurid Empire civilization. It feels like they are more focused on retaining their existing player base rather than appealing to a broader audience. I hope I’m wrong.
I don’t know whether the game is profitable, but it certainly isn’t getting the recognition it deserves.
Well, keeping the base players is the best way to bring newcomers by active communoty. Or you need to do terrible update like the october 2024 pacth. The siege and def nerf for permeting control player enter in the game. Bad idea and terrible for the balencing, from my opinion… but we get new players, at some cost…
KT is no more a variant than jin dynasty. Let’s be honest on it. But JA need something… that thing is horrible in gameplay and historically speaking.
The real JA never killed (at least her inquisiion trial fail to prove it) so she should be a super mekhter, not a figther! Royal knigths? Way too redundant… and stupid in time of civil war for the crown. But they can have a use of the Gendarme instead! (with armor buff if succeded charge) and but the compagnions and hrosam of JA to feudal. It’s not a hudge update. One new unic unit and 2 new skins for feudal, and it would feel not so French like even more agressive variant. They could also replace 3 landmarks ( chevalery school, royal institut and red keep) by chruch that buff JA ability of support. Had more uniques tech eco and army dépending of JA evolution. And give choice between JA buffing éco or army.
Sorry for disgression but JA is exactly the wrong type of new content that may be a danger for the aoe…
JA definitely needs something, yes. For example, to be removed from the game. You could give him to the French as a hero, just like Batu Khan for the Golden Horde. But presenting a hero as an entirely separate variant civilization is beyond ridiculous. This means we’ll probably see El Cid as well when the Spanish civilization is introduced. Thankfully, the developers haven’t started discussing the idea of adding every single Ottoman Sultan to the game as a separate variant civilization.
So you werent even know what they are weak against even tho you played them lot nice defend for low learning curve person just as expected.
This is not a balance post i opened this post if you want to discuss balance problems have some coruage and open a post or do you need to learn couple of months to how to open a post.
For truly unique units Vikings just have the Berserker, the Shield Maiden, and the Volur.
The spearman, MaA, crossbow, and knight are “unique” replacements, but they aren’t that different. They still counter and are countered by the typical units.
The crossbows and knights are weaker cheaper versions. They definitely need some weaker units like this if they’re going to be allowed to have over 200 pop in the end game (Of which I am still skeptical).
You’re absolutely right. Their units are already very strong, and they can reach a population of 220. Why? Their resources are practically unlimited already.
In my opinion, the civilization that should receive a population cap increase is the Golden Horde. They could make the Karash count as 0.5 population. Just an idea
Yes it is it resembles the what character can do,their roles.If a hammer holding unit cant deal bonus to armour depth of the game is gone.Anything can happen in this game until it reaches ridiculousness.
Sorry but no, you are using “depth” incorrectly. Maybe you mean to say it is inconsistent or unintuitive, but depth is not the word you are looking for.