Thoughts on the Scottish Border Reivers and Mongol Raids

The Scottish Border Reivers are the core of this DLC. I hope they will not be nerfed.

However! The game needs improvement! Two major improvements are needed.

  1. Currently, almost no players use walls to block cavalry harassment. The build time of walls should be shortened, with the goal of making Mongol raids viable again. It was the nerfing of walls that led to the subsequent nerfing of Mongol raids. Because walls became difficult to build, Mongol raids became too strong. In fact, the Border Reivers will also be nerfed in the future for this reason. But I don’t want the game to reduce gameplay options—instead, I want it to revisit and undo previous mistaken nerfs.

  2. Reduce the wood cost of Trebuchets and increase the range of Cannons and Culverins. (As a result, repairing Keeps—i.e., Castles—should reduce the stone cost, or change the stone cost to wood.) In short: strengthen walls, then strengthen siege weapons, so that the Scottish Border Reivers will not be nerfed. Also consider a slight buff to Palisades.

Actually, there are currently the following ways to counter the Scottish Border Reivers:

  1. Build Palisades to buffer the Border Reivers’ movement (even though they will be burned down by the riders accompanying them).

  2. If allowed, you should build Stone Walls, but currently Stone Walls cannot be built—because they are too expensive and consume too much villager work time.

  3. Have enough Archers and deploy them in advance. If you have enough Horsemen and a small number of heavy Knights in your composition, that can also work.

  4. Build Keeps or Castle landmarks.

  5. Build Outposts and upgrade them with Springald emplacements.

Border Reivers’dont need rider to acompany them, they got 21 torch damage themselves. Clearly OP, since they can’t be stopped by wood walls at all then.

Also, Border Reivers should not be instantle summonable in castle age, it is simply too strong, oppos do not have time to build counter units unless they start before the unit even existed, taking a gamble.

1 Like

Focusing on team games, I completely agree that border reivers are too strong in Castle age, even when you know they are coming. Their counter units (archers) don’t actually trade all that well in practice, because they lack the mobility to decide when engagements occur and are easily countered by cavalry (or matched by archers) that pair well with the border reivers.

The border reivers that instantly pop up in Castle age is such an abrupt power spike that there’s very little that can realistically be done to punish them in an actual game. Even with something like Burgrave (or other FC play) where you get a fast production building as a landmark or Castle age power spike, you can counter that strategically by denying resources or by picking off individual units that trickle in. With the Border Reivers, they just pop up and mow down everything.