Poll closed, results and analysis. People had only 3 votes for their fav civs. Sample, 145 forum users.
Rank
Civ
%
Region/Culture
Continent
1
Persia
76
Central Asia
Asia
2
Siam
23
South-Est Asia
Asia
3
Korea
22
Est Asia
Asia
4
Brazil
22
Post-colonial European civ
South America
5
Morocco
17
Arab Country
Africa
6
Austria
15
European civ
Europe
7
Oman
13
Arab Country
Asia
8
Zulu
9
South African natives
Africa
9
Mapuche
8
South American natives
South America
10
Burma
8
South-Est Asia
Asia
11
Argentina
6
Post-colonial European civ
South America
12
Afghans
5
Central Asia
Asia
13
Colombia
5
Post-colonial European civ
South America
If we go traditional DE expansion DLC, we would choose 2.
By pure rank:Persia and Siam would be the more voted
By region:Persia and Afghans would add the most % (81%) because the far margin of Persia. Persia and Oman would add even more (89%), but I put different labels on them (and you know, labels always have some kind of arbitrariness)
By continent: Asia seems the most popular choice, followed of South America.
Following that pair, I guess Korea and Burma could be a popular one (Sorry, I forgot Vietnam on the poll, and I’m aware about the Korea discussion about if they fit or not as a major power). Morocco and Oman could be also interesting if they don’t include the later with Persia.
Keep in mind that The Baltic Powers could have been the last DLC. But if you like discussing civs, feel free to discuss it here and not on a random topic of the feedback of balance.
The most hated civs between Chinese and non-Chinese people here on the forums, especially Burmese which gets belitteled because it got colonized at the end of AoE3DE’s timeline while conquering all of Siam like twice.
Hopefully the poll won’t affect much since some good potential civs always get neglected like Afghans.
I am a Chinese player, and I have been speaking for Myanmar for a long time, hoping to let some people know that Myanmar is a very powerful country in early modern times.
I warned in the previous poll topic that I didnt know much about sub-Saharan African history. Kongo and Mutapa, Asante or Sennar could be nice additions, but they didnt got much votes
Yes, they’ll do one of each, but on a regional level… a popular civilization (Persia/Tatars) with a less so one (Morocco/Oman/Afghans)… then in East Asia, Siamese with Burma and Korea with Vietnam…
Of course…the Burmese in AoE 3 literally start with Bayinnung or after his death…
I don’t judge them, the Zulus are very popular (the same thing happens in the Civilization saga since Civ 1)…
Anyone suggesting a “post-colonial” something obviously doesn’t understand the concept of the game.
Let me phrase it simply: the game allows the player the play the colonizer OR the colonized.
The “post-colonial” is basically your post game, or late game, if you want.
So you can suggest a “pre-colonized / colonizing” Brazilian civ, for example (was long enough). Not a “post-colonial” Brazilian civ. That’s it.
A Brazil civilization would need to incorporate both pre-independence and post-independence content. Post-colonial is just a term used in the poll to separate cultures/regions from American natives and European civs. The Brazil civilization would probably follow the Federal States age-up system that the USA and Mexico use.
Burma is probably extremely unpopular because it’s locked on a perpetual civil war nowadays so that’s pretty much the only thing you ever hear about it in the news if ever.
You don’t know the absurd lengths I had to go to find military history books about Toungoo/Kounbang and whatnot.
I’m more surprised Vietnam didn’t even make it into the discussion though.
That’s unfortunate…The more I’ve read about them the more it made me realize that they fit AoE3DE perfectly, especially with Bayinnaung, kinda lame how AoE2’ Burmese has a Manipur unit instead of a Burmese one (Perhaps it would be a perfect card unit).
Feels like one of the civs along with TLC and Koreans (Not the War Wagon lol) that would’ve been great for AoE3DE.
Manipur Cavalry would perfectly fit (AoE3) Burma, in the same sense that Cossacks are part of the russian roster or Oromo Cavalry in Ethiopia, they were a fundamental part of the early modern Burmese army.