The game is good but right now I feel like it restricts some of the “joy” of Age of Empires. While by no means essential things, these are indeed some aspects that make AoE what it is.
A lot of these may be “unnecessary”, but in a bid to bring new players to the RTS genre, AoE4 doesn’t do any service to long term Age players who they claim have been instrumental in the development of AoE4. Yes, in a competitive setting it doesn’t matter what’s red or Blue, whether an animal is a sheep or a cow as long as it has 250 food in it. But these things have been an integral part of what AoE is.
Here are the things I really want, so that this AoE game is like the AoE games I have loved since childhood. Feel free to suggest more. I hope the devs read this and give us these down the line.
-
Changing color of your faction: yeah, it doesn’t matter in a competitive setting if I’m red or blue. Only strategy should matter, right? Well… no. I can spend hours playing the game with blue units, but I don’t feel as happy as when I’m red. Sometimes even yellow or purple. I don’t like blue ALL the time. Sigh.
-
Viewing the map after the game: yes, unnecessary since the game is over. I’ve either won or lost. But please, won’t you let me gloat over the map and look at my units, their shiny upgrades, their stats. I wanna see my town that’s doing so well. I want to see the idle villagers gazing over the deforestation. I want to see these things! Why can I not see the map after a game ends?
-
Favorite military unit in post-game stats: did I mostly play archers, or elephants, or Lancers? I wanna know what my most created unit was.
-
Let me pick a random civ?
-
Let me ungarrison units from buildings one at a time? Why can’t I do this in AoE4 when I could easily do this in all other Age games?
-
Let me zoom up to the clouds and down to the berries. Guys, look at AoE3DE right now. Beautiful zoom. You can zoom down to see the mustache on the janissary and you can zoom all the way out to see your entire base at a go.
-
Siege destruct animation: my siege weapons go poof. AoE2 DE has better siege animation than this. You spent so much effort animating building destruction so perfectly but you didn’t do anything for the siege?
-
I want a scenario editor to compare units and tweak stats and just have fun messing with units.
-
Just sheep and deer is so boring. Can we please have other huntables and herdables on the map. Cows maybe? Or you know, huntable bison or yak or whatever. Just not sheep and deer.
-
Some cannon physics… archer got hit by a cannon and behaved like if was shot by an arrow. Where’s the conservation of momentum? I have a genuine question here: is adding physics to cannonfire going to mess with gameplay somehow? All the emphasis on realism and such realistic ways to die for the units, and yet, when they are hit by a cannonball, all realism is gone!
-
Why do my archers slide forward like they’re on ice before they shoot an arrow?
-
And why do torches and cannon projectiles trajectories not have a parabolic shape. Instead they have sharp interpolation points. Even on good computers.
-
'A.I. hardest has reached the Imperial age". Which one? There are 4 hardest AIs in my game. Dammit, which one went imperial? Can we have AI personalities? Makes much more sense to give each AI player a name. Right now I’m not sure this notification even helps.
-
Taunts: add player taunts. Also AI taunts…Queen Isabella in AOE3 is a meme… “Is that your explorer I saw napping in a field? He needs a spanking!” Would love the AI in AoE4 do these. Some of the most entertaining things about AoE3 was when AI players made these funny taunts! Hehe.
AoE is not company of heroes. I don’t play it just for the strategy or the competition (I play the game to relax and bully my friend the AI)…but it’s so much more. For the competitive player, its an RTS, but for others, it’s a relaxing game to maybe build a big base in and enjoy the views. For me it’s just a way to be active without actually thinking too much. There’s a lot going on in life and the reason I play is not to optimize a build order, it’s to do Age of Empires things and chill.
I have been completing masteries and stuff… and it’s fun. But I still don’t think this product is quite there yet. But I hope it will be soon.