Sword icon killing doesn't work on friendly food animals

:play_button: GAME INFORMATION

  • GAME BUILD #: 130746
  • GAME PLATFORM: Steam
  • OPERATING SYSTEM: Windows 11

:play_button: ISSUE EXPERIENCED

When scout or other military targets an adoptable or heardable friendly food animal (sheep, turkey, llama, deer, etc.) that is still neutral, the sword icon appears. But when you try to attack/kill said animal by right-mousing with the sword icon showing, your unit instead adopts the animal when you get close to it.

Windows screenshot isn’t capturing the icon so I’ve made a poor drawing of it:

:play_button: EXPECTED RESULT

It should kill the animal

  • In mid- or late-game this could come in handy because it gets tiresome to hear the cowbell sheep sound every time your trade carts go by a sheep, and then your ally’s carts do, and then yours do, and then your ally’s, etc. for 10, 20, or 30 minutes… until one of you takes time to put a villager on it. At this point in the game, though, I just want the sheep gone because we have a bunch of farms and are busy with battles. Would be much easier to send a cavalry to kill it so you can one-click do that (and not have to worry about an idle villager after harvesting the sheep if a villy is used)
  • And in earlier AoE2s, weren’t you able to kill sheep and deer, or am I mistaken? If so, why not now?

If killing it with the sword icon is absolutely not desired, then the icon should not change to a sword at all… it should stay an arrow shape and not mislead us.

As a compromise, maybe after adopting the animal is when it should switch to sword, whereby it is then killable by right-mousing it?

No matter what, the sword icon is currently incorrect and misleading

EDIT: Saw a TTL4 Platinum vid showing you can only kill sheep and such if it has been claimed by the enemy and is their color. If the icon could only show in proper context that would be nice. But also I still think we should be able to kill sheep+ whenever we want

1 Like

Hi @Darkness01101

Thanks for the feedback about the sword icon with the herdable. I´ll pass it on to the team.

1 Like

Thanks, @IvanHCastro ! I’ve been thinking/wondering recently if the sword icon should maybe be relegated to appear only with a key modifier action when the animal is a friendly or neutral color to avoid accidental killing

For example, hold SHIFT, ALT, or CTRL to make the sword appear in the friendly/neutral color cases for when you right-click. I say this because when deer pushing, I’ve seen it would be super easy to accidentally kill the deer you’re trying to push if the sword was working currently… and yet I’d still like the option to kill it