As we get more and more info of AoE4 all our expectations start to bubble. Since they dropped the news I have been worried for a continued development as the “less popularized” games of the series.
I think I speak for many of the AoE2 crowd, and if they don’t mind us, I think that the community will be further divided and AoE2 (DE) will continue to be the most played game of the series and that AoE4 wont be the successor that we all have been waiting for.
Fortification builder:
Hopefully the game dont become the fortification and citybuilder as we see in the trailer. I know that a lot of the casual crowd like to play slow, build a big base (and city) and a grand army and attack after 30 min. BUT I think that walls need to be a big investment and that it doesnt becom standard in the game. As we all have seen i Aoe2 tournaments, walls isnt that common and rushes are. This need to continue.
Hero units
This turned me off extremely. I can accept the kind of hero-units in AoM with the passive abilities, but to include a hero unit with active (usable) actions and 3x HP and x2 attack of a “normal” unit is unrealisric, boring and just takes another game mechanic from a lesser played game. One of the core elements of AoE2 for me is that “all units” are equal or equivalent.
Unit HP,
Something else that I think Aoe3 and AoM did that AoE2 dnt have was the ridicculusly HPed units. Musketmen in Aoe3 can shoot eachother with like 20 shots and still live. I know its “almost the same” in AoE2 but having a single knight rushing against 12 archers, i needs to die after 2nd or thrid volley.
“Snare” or other “battle elements”
as fatigue or stun NEEDS TO BE EXCLUDED, this is the one factor I dislike with the Aoe3 and AoM games, just watch SOTL video on the subject.
TLDR:
Don’t make this game to “Fortification builder” or Total War, don’t include the aspects that every other RTS game has (Heroes, Elite units, status effects). You don’t need to be everything, you just need to be the Age of Empires which we all want. And I think that AoE2 needs to be the template and AoE3 DE and AoM need to step back, the were less favourable of the reasons we all know, especially the developers. Dont try to “fix” the problem, dont include it from the start.