My Honest opinion after almost two years

Indeed. Since DE is the most recent version of AoE 2, I think it makes sense to use these icons instead of the legacy ones.


Agreed, Bracer seems random which is why Ensemble probably provided small history/trivia techs for each tech in the manual:
bracer manual

Fair 11 I was ironcially enough too lazy to open both games in instead copied the URLs from the fan wiki which resulted in the icons being bigger.

1 Like

Another hot take: I donā€™t actually hate AoEIVā€™s UI lol. Itā€™s definitely a bit jarring but you can understand what Relic was attempting to do here whether or not you agree with the reasoning. I think it is more intuitive than AoE2s concerning tech upgrades. The unit icons themselves could have used more flavor I think. The bronze background with the gold unit highlight just seems a bit off to me.

Still, I much prefer the artwork displayed in the previous games. In short, the UI isnā€™t what turned me off the game.

3 Likes

I agree, and this isnā€™t related to you comparing the icons at all, it reaches back to something I was discussing earlier, about completeness, etc. More me just rambling now really :smiley:

AoE II was a finished game. The DE is another edition on top on that. The original icon detail wouldnā€™t have come across as detailed; as sharp. But in the re-release, this polish was applied. And weā€™re comparing it to a game that has gotten a single release.

Itā€™s actually a really fascinating deep dive into player psychology and iconography, but this prolly isnā€™t the thread for it haha. Iā€™m not saying youā€™re wrong to use them either.

2 Likes

show aoeo upgrades icons. they have the similar style like aoe 4 but has effort on them for the contrast of what aoe 4 ui could beā€¦

2 Likes

AoEO UI is the best. Here is the military tech tree for the Indians, which is a mix of some original techs and icons plus new ones our artists made recently. I think they ooze personality. Compare to AoE4.

3 Likes

############### post:150, topic:234575"]
Take look at all the popular games from mobile games like Candy Crash
[/quote]

############### post:150, topic:234575"]
They are not big because they would be complex and hard to play.
[/quote]

Oh OMG, you are picking Candy crashā€¦ COD etc and saying they are hard to play xD
Ok, I think you are 3-5 years old kid at this moment.

COD is basically WASD and click mouse 1 and 2ā€¦ Anyone can play itā€¦
Candy crash is just about matching colours etcā€¦
And you say they are hardā€¦
They are one of the easiest game there ever!

And COD is not a small game!
90GB for MWII
Campaign 4+ hours content,
Spec ops, MP, Warzone etc lots of huge contentsā€¦

Ahh, you dont have any experience in talking games at this stage and I lost my interest to youā€¦

So you just admitted that you canā€™t read and engage in reasonable discussion.

############### post:153, topic:234575"]
AoE4 with broken sword & arrow does better job at showing the intention.
[/quote]

So it was supposed to break weapons, not to decrease damage xD
hahahahahahha
You are pulling AOE4 UI into a shame xD

############### post:161, topic:234575, full:true"]
So you just admitted that you canā€™t read and engage in reasonable discussion.
[/quote]

Your discussion is 3-4 year old kidā€™s mindā€¦
Which I consider useless.
Thank you!

Yeah, discussing with kid that fails to use basic quotation is pointless. As well as any attempt with person that starts making attack against other person due to difference in opinion. But at least I tried to discuss it with you. You chose to show what you are.

1 Like

############### post:166, topic:234575"]
You chose to show what you are.
[/quote]

I did make you feel like a baby because I am an alpha male.

I canā€™t wait for the Indiansā€¦

1 Like

unpopular opinion here, aoe3 og looks better than aoe3 DE, sorry but aoe3:DE textures in some cases look TOO clean and kinda cartoony too, i also preffer how the water looks in the OG version.

(aoe3 DE still has a superior landscape + nature, dont get me wrong but i think i preffer the OG one) , maybe its my nostalgia childhood, idk but i preffer the 2005 og AoE3.

1 Like

Butā€¦I like AOE3 DE :stuck_out_tongue_closed_eyes:

1 Like

sure both looks better than aoe 4 one

1 Like

imo, cliffs like these instantly attract my eyes


also notice thereā€™s rain thats just there for atmosphere of a map, smt aoe4 could use more of
to be fair, this is a very busy screenshot for just terrain, but point is, you can still borrow elements of whats present here and simply redo them with aoe4ā€™s style in mind, itā€™d look really good even in that style

9 Likes

Iā€™M really sorry to say it like this:
Compared to aoe3, aoe4 is just a huge disappointment in any regard.
You canā€™t even compare them.
Aoe4 is alpha/beta, aoe3de is finished release.

My friend and me decided to leave aoe4, we are going back to aoe3de.
Itā€™s just too painful, so many things are not thought through, graphics are 2/10 for 2021 game, tons of bugs, almost no communication about further development, boring boom meta, you canā€™t ungarrison units to the chosen direction and and andā€¦
Thank you Relic!

13 Likes

Again, environment seems to have little to no effort in AoE4. Lots of reused assets like trees makes each biome feel the same, furthermore, biomes do not feel like the intended biomes. No using of colour temperature, no use of effects like sand storms or snow, rain, mist, no use of anythnig to give it a feel.

Really disappointed by it. I doubt it will ever change.

10 Likes

lets just say it as is, current maps and how flora and fauna are handled is very clearly targeting 1 crowd, the competitive hardcores

1 Like

Yes, I agreeā€¦AoE 4 should look that goodā€¦

Yes, it has a lot of potential, but they end up making it a bland game all because of the damn competitiveā€¦

The game needs 5 things to improve:

  1. Improve the graphics a bit more, so that it looks similar to AoE 3 DEā€¦

  2. More civs, campaigns, flora and fauna

  3. More unique units for the HRE (Teutonic knight, Hussite wagon and Reiter)ā€¦

  4. That the villagers can build wooden and stone bridges like in the Mongol Empire campaignā€¦

  5. Day and night cycle as in AoM

6 Likes