Have you ever wondered which civ has the strongest Explorer? I have, that’s why I decided to check out every single civilization’s main Hero to see how strong and useful they can get. In this topic I’m going to talk about Western Heroes(European and Post-Colonial Americans) since they share a lot of skills. Native Americans, Asians and Africans will be covered in another topic in the future.
First, some rules:
- I tested all Heroes at their absolute peak. That means using every possible card and technology that benefited them in some way or another.
- I didn’t use native allies or treasures buffs to improve them further, since these depend on map choice. I also didn’t use any Team bonuses from other civs.
The only exception to this rule is when they are a part of the civilization trough Home City or Federal States cards, such as the Cree for the US and the Jesuit and Aztecs for the Mexicans.
- A small part of the bonuses available to the US and Mexican Generals are mutually exclusive, since they require you to pick only one Federal State during age-up.
For example: If you pick California on Age IV, you can get the Bear Flag upgrade, but if you pick Ohio in Age IV you can get an extra Fort. You can’t have both at the same time, if you pick California, you won’t get this extra Fort and if you pick Ohio, you won’t get the Bear Flag upgrade.
HP and Armor: Most civs Explorers peak at 3220HP. The Dutch and Portuguese can reach 3280HP and the British and Spanish can reach 3300HP, just slightly higher than average. As for Armor, they all have the same 10% Armor against ranged attacks.
Points to Britain and Spain, I guess.
Speed: The average Explorer peaks at a speed of 4.95. Interestingly, the British and Dutch are actually slower than average, sacrificing their movement speed for other attributes. Dutch explorers move at 4.50 and British at a glacial 3.83. On the flip side, Germans and Ottomans have the fastest Explorers, the Germans with speeds of 5.85 and the Ottomans with 5.95.
Point for the Ottomans.
Attack: Just looking at their attack stats, there is barely any difference between the Explorers at all. They all have a 43 ranged attack, 21 hand attack and 39 siege attack with +200% damage vs. treasure guardians and -75% damage vs. villagers. However, some civs do have a very slight edge on this matter.
French Explorers have +1 in both ranged and hand attacks and +2 in siege. Spanish Explorers are even better, having +2 in both ranged and siege attacks and +1 in hand attacks. They can be further boosted by their Missionaries that give them extra +2 ranged attack and +1 hand and siege attacks.
Russian Explorers have an extra bonus of +200% damage vs. Treasure Guardians, for a total of +400% damage against Guardians. However, when fighting other units, they are just average.
Points to Spain for the best general combat Explorer and to Russia for the best anti-guardian combat.
Building: When it comes to building, I guess we can look at it from two perspectives. Who can build the fastest and who can build the most.
When it comes to speed, there are only two Explorers that stand out. German Explorers build Town Centers and Trading Posts 100% faster; While Russian Explorers can build Town Centers and Forts 100% faster. All others build at the same speed.
Now, how much each can build varies wildly from civ to civ. Ottomans can build up to 9 Town Centers and Portuguese up to 12 Town Centers. French and Swedes can get up to 4 Forts, 1 more than the rest. Germans and Portuguese can only build up to 7 Outposts(all other European civs can reach 14) and Russians can’t build outposts or blockhouses at all. Then there are the Dutch which have a -50% discount on wood costs for Town Centers.
It’s impossible to declare any of them to be the “objectively best” builder since they have different attributes that are useful or not depending on your playstyle and situation.
Companions: All Explorers can summon Hot Air Balloons, for a time, and almost all Explorers have a canine companion that is also a Hero unit. The only exception is the Spanish, which can train up to 5 War Dogs instead of having 1 Hero Dog. But arguably the best companion available to an Explorer is another Explorer, available only to the Portuguese.
While the War Dogs are very useful in the early game, having 2 Explorers ultimately trumps that. Point to Portugal.
Unique Specials and others: All Explorers have some sort of unique attribute to them unlocked by their civ’s explorer upgrade card, some have already been mentioned before, but here is a full quick list:
- British: Have a Special Swashbuckler Attack.
- Dutch: -50% wood discount on Town Centers.
- French: Can heal friendly units.
- Germans: Build Town Centers and Trading Posts 100% faster.
- Ottomans: Have +1.00 speed.
- Portuguese: Have the Special Spyglass ability(always available, but gets upgraded).
- Russians: Have +200% extra damage vs. Treasure Guardians.
- Spanish: Can train War Dogs(always available, but gets upgraded).
- Swedes: Have a Special Heavy Strike Attack.
Other notable unique bonuses gained elsewhere are:
- Russians: Build Town Centers and Forts 100% faster.
- Spanish: Have +10 LOS.
- Swedes: Can get +100% XP generation when near Forts.
Again, it’s impossible to declare an “objectively best” Explorer here since we are talking about very different skills that may or may not be useful to you depending on the scenario.
Personal Verdict: All in all, my favorite is the Spanish Explorer. They have the best HP, Attack and LOS. You can access most of their buffs very early in the game, when they are the most consequential, and the easily affordable war dogs can chew through most Treasure Guardians with ease as well as help with exploration and combat. Portugal and France are my second and third favorites. The Dutch and Ottoman Explorers are my least favorite.
HP and Armor: Both the US and Mexico’s generals have considerably more HP than their european counterparts. The US General’s peak HP is 3650HP and can be increased by +182HP when near a Inspiring Flag with the Land of Lincoln card upgrade. The Mexican General’s peak is 4025HP and can be increased by +125HP when near a Fort with the Cinco de Mayo card upgrade. Both have 10% ranged armor, the same as European Explorers.
This one is not even close, point for the Mexicans.
Speed: The US General can reach the same peak speed as a generic Explorer, 4.95. Mexican Generals can be slightly faster, reaching speeds of 5.18. Not much else to say.
Point to Mexico.
Attack: The peak US General has similar ranged and hand attacks to those of a peak Spanish Explorer, 44 ranged attack and 22 hand attack, but a much higher siege damage, 56. All of those can be boosted by roughly 10% with the Inspiring Flag, reaching 49 for ranged, 24 for hand and 61 for siege. They also have a weaker version of the Russian Explorer’s unique bonus, having an additional +100% damage against Treasure Guardians and +100% damage vs. Outlaws(which doesn’t show properly on the HUD). Despite the rather beefy stats, the US General is once again trumped by his mexican colleague.
Mexican Generals, at their peak, have 56 ranged attack, 28 hand attack and 70 siege attack, exceeding all other Heroes we saw so far. These numbers can be boosted further by two different auras that are stackable: The Inspiring Flag and the Cinco de Mayo Fort auras. Reaching total attack numbers of 63 for ranged, 32 for hand and 79 for siege.
Again, not even close, point for the Mexicans.
Building: One area in which Generals are rather lackluster is building stuff. While Explorers can build Town Centers, Trading Posts, Native Embassies, Outposts and Forts, Generals can only build Forts and Trading Posts. Both Mexican and US Generals can build up to 6 Forts at a time, but the the Mexican General can unlock more buildings through Home City and Federal States cards. These are: Up to 3 Native Embassies, up to 7 Outposts and up to 4 (free) Field Jospitals.
Yet again, not even close, point for the Mexicans.
Companions: US Generals can summon 1 Hot Air Balloon temporarily, that’s it.
Mexicans can also summon a Hot Air Balloon through their General, but they can have a 2nd General AND The Padre, which is also a Hero with its own wide set of powerful skills on the battlefield. And there is more, Mexican Generals can also gain the ability to train Soldados from their position, wherever they are.
Point for the Mexicans. You might have started to notice a pattern here…
Inspiring Flag: Both american generals share the ability to place an Inspiring Flag on the map with increasing AoEs to boost friendly troops and buildings. By default the Flags grant: +10% damage to units, +25% workrate for military buildings and +50% construction speed for all buildings.
The US has arguably the more powerful Flag. Besides all previously stated buffs, it also grants +5% HP to nearby units with the Land of Lincoln card and, if you pick California, you unlock the Bear Flag which spawns 6 Honcho the Grizzly Bears everytime you replace the Flag on the map. Meanwhile, the Mexican Flag also has all the default buffs, but it can be upgraded to grant a further +25% workrate for military buildings. But here’s the kicker, with the Man of Destiny card, Generals also have the same aura as Flags, meaning that you won’t even need to place Flags as Mexico. And it functions for both Mexican Generals, meaning you can use your two Generals and the flag to 3 cover different large sections of the map with the Inspiring Flag aura effects.
While the US do have a stronger aura, I still think that Mexico takes this because of its practicality and massive coverage area.
Unique Specials and others: Finally we have the other unique skills and bonuses that don’t fit in the other categories. Firstly, both American Generals share the Sharpshooter Attack ability with all the European Explorers. As for the rest of abilities… Sadly, this will be another stomp for Mexico. American Generals have the unique charged Carbine Attack, which functions similarly to the Sharpshooter Attack, but weaker. The Mexican Generals can:
- Use a charged Saber Strike
- Have an extra +8 LOS and/or an extra +100% LOS(they stack)
- Spawn Militiaman whenever they are killed
- Generate Food as well as XP when destroying buildings
- Receive Home City Shipments from any place on the map
This one is just embarrassing, point for the Mexicans.
Personal Verdict: I was genuinely shocked at just how powerful and flexible Mexican Generals can be, they have so many possible abilities that you can even break their unit menu in the HUD. They are not necessarily OP, but they do make all other Heroes we saw so far look weak by comparison, especially the US General which you would expect to be on the same level as the Mexican one.